Supreme Court Rejects Suspension of Ruling on Finance Act 2023, Deepening Fiscal Crisis
On Friday, August 2, the Supreme Court of Kenya dealt a setback to the National Treasury by denying its request to halt the nullification of the Finance Act 2023.
This ruling jeopardizes the country’s economic stability, intensifying the fiscal uncertainty that has already plagued Kenya due to recent legislative changes.
The Court’s decision to deny the stay means the Finance Act 2023, previously invalidated by the Court of Appeal for being unconstitutional, remains invalid.
This judgment arrives at a particularly challenging time for Kenya, which is already dealing with the withdrawal of the Finance Bill 2024.
With the Finance Act 2023 annulled and no alternative revenue plan established, the government now faces the daunting challenge of managing finances with a Ksh510 billion deficit in the national budget for the current fiscal year.
The Supreme Court’s ruling not only dismissed the Treasury’s request but also classified the issue as urgent, setting a hearing during the August court recess.
This prompt action by the Apex Court underscores the seriousness of the situation and the urgent need for a resolution.
The court’s ruling requires the Treasury and other relevant parties to submit their motions and responses quickly, adding to the pressure on all involved.
Under significant strain, the National Treasury sought a stay to delay the immediate enforcement of the Court of Appeal’s ruling, hoping to buy time to adjust its fiscal policies.
The Finance Act 2023, which had introduced several controversial tax increases, including a major hike in VAT on fuel and new income tax bands, was seen as essential for the government’s revenue-raising efforts. Its invalidation has created a significant gap in the fiscal framework, worsening Kenya’s already precarious economic condition.
ALSO READ:
- Gachagua Assembles Elite 20-Lawyer Squad to Fight Impeachment
- Exposed: Web of 19 Companies That Could Make or Break Gachagua in Impeachment Battle
- Makau Mutua Predicts Rigathi Gachagua Will Resign Before His Impeachment on Tuesday
- CSs Joho, Mbadi & Barasa Announce Key Appointments
- Ruto’s Ksh303B Borrowing Pushes Public Debt to Ksh10.5 Trillion, Set to Reach Ksh13 Trillion by 2028
The ruling has sparked widespread debate across the nation. For many Kenyans, the Court of Appeal’s decision represented a rare win against perceived government overreach.
Citizens burdened by rising taxes viewed the judgment as a victory for ordinary taxpayers. However, this judicial triumph is tempered by the practical repercussions, as the government scrambles for solutions.
The Treasury contends that the Finance Act 2023 was crucial for meeting revenue goals, and its nullification will lead to an estimated loss of Ksh164 billion. This shortfall could critically affect the government’s capacity to finance essential services and infrastructure projects.
The stakes are undeniably high. The Finance Act 2023 aimed to alleviate Kenya’s fiscal pressures through increased taxation. It proposed significant changes, such as doubling VAT on fuel from 8 percent to 16 percent and introducing new income tax bands for high earners.
These measures were intended to enhance government revenues, but their unpopularity among the public, combined with recent court decisions, has disrupted the administration’s financial plans.
As the country awaits the Supreme Court’s final ruling on the appeal, the government must navigate a complex fiscal landscape.
Experts suggest that, without the Finance Act 2023, the administration might revert to the Finance Bill of 2022, though this would not fully address the revenue shortfall.
This transition could face considerable challenges, given the shifting economic context and the need for legislative changes.
The current situation highlights the delicate balance between tax policy, judicial oversight, and public opinion. The Finance Act 2023’s path from introduction to nullification reflects broader issues of governance and accountability in Kenya.
The court’s decisions are not just legal judgments but are deeply connected to the country’s economic well-being and public confidence in its institutions.
Supreme Court Rejects Suspension of Ruling on Finance Act 2023, Deepening Fiscal Crisis
